Episode 96 : My Bloody Valentine

When couples start eating each other to death, the brothers investigate and find angelic marks on the victims’ hearts. They call Castiel, who suspects a Cupid to be responsible for the deaths. Castiel summons the Cupid and asks him about the strange incidents, but the angel of love says he is only acting on higher orders, but that killings are not his work. After examining another victim’s body, Sam follows a suspicious man and confronts him. Sam fights him and grazes him with Ruby’s knife, which reveals his demonic nature. The demon flees and leaves his briefcase behind, and Sam finds his addiction to demon blood return. Soon, people start dying from binge eating or alcohol poisoning, and Castiel develops a weird craving for red meat, which leads them to believe that one of the Four Horsemen, Famine, who causes people to give in to their desires, is behind the deaths. They open the briefcase, which contains a human soul. Castiel states that Famine harvests the souls of the people he killed and consumes them. Later, Dean and Castiel set out to face Famine and cut off the finger on which he wears the ring containing his power. They lock up Sam in order to prevent him from deferring to his cravings and follow the demons who harvested a soul for Famine to devour. Meanwhile, demons enter the room where Sam is chained up. Sam breaks free, attacks the demons and satisfies his burning thirst. When Dean and Castiel arrive at the diner in which they suspect Famine to dwell, Castiel enters the building in order to attack Famine, but is held up by his desire for food. Dean walks in and is assaulted by demons. Famine says that Dean is not responding to his curse because he is empty inside and there is nothing that can satisfy his hunger. When Sam suddenly appears, Famine offers him the demons guarding himself, but Sam refuses. He exorcizes them, and Famine devours their essences. Sam tries to use his powers on the Horseman, but Famine states that Sam’s abilities will not work on him. Instead of killing the Horseman himself, Sam uses his powers to drive out the demons Famine has just swallowed, which ultimately kills the Horseman. In the end, Dean and Castiel lock Sam up in order to get the demon blood out of his system. When Dean cannot bear Sam’s screams anymore, he walks outside and prays to God for help.